how is my gamer name of Dirty Bearded Jew racist? i am a Dirty Bearded Jew. please someone tell me why i was banned from a group i am part of for the same name i had when i was invited
Invalid racism
- Thread starter dbj4837
- Start date
-
If you are not the person that was banned/muted, you are only allowed to post evidence. Trash talk is unnecessary.
- Status
http://www.skial.com/threads/requests-that-dont-follow-this-format-will-be-ignored.28/
"Dirty Bearded Jew" sounds anti semitic to me which falls under the no racism rule.
"Dirty Bearded Jew" sounds anti semitic to me which falls under the no racism rule.
i've been a member of this group for over a year and as i said i am a jew and i'm only calling myself a dirty bearded jew
ego banned me for the same reason only to find out it was really cuz i was badly domming one of the admins and talked shit. i'm still banned from ego and still a member
I cant see this being racist, I mean if you had the name dirty bearded American or dirty bearded catholic it wouldn't be seen as racist.
Maybe this question could have been asked back in August when he was banned the first time?
http://www.skial.com/sourcebans/ind...arch=STEAM_0:0:2725586&advType=steamid&Submit
http://www.skial.com/sourcebans/ind...arch=STEAM_0:0:2725586&advType=steamid&Submit
the "talked shit" was probably what caused you to get banned on ego servers as they dont allow any foul, degrading or racist remarks
Guys, Dirty bearded jew, is not racist, dirty is an adjective for beard. Not for jew. There is no adjective for Jew in his name.
Cylosis
Legendary Skial King
Right. And I could be named "dirty fucking black man" and get away with it.
Oh, the black guy isn't dirty, he's just wild in bed.
You have had the name for a long time on Skial and I find it weird that no other admins have seen you with the name before so I see your point. However, there is no way for you to prove you are a Jew just like there is no way for someone to prove they are black so we don't allow racism even from those who say they are. I also don't see why a Jew would stretch the common anti Semitic "dirty Jew" into a "Dirty Bearded Jew" - either way it's not ok. We can't allow racism and somehow allow antisemitism.
You also have an interesting name history with names like "Generic Racist Name", "lets play: wack a jew", and "the one bible warns of" - I suppose these could have different interpretations and are borderline but with your previous ban for racism I'm learning towards over the line.
You still haven't followed the correct format.
You also have an interesting name history with names like "Generic Racist Name", "lets play: wack a jew", and "the one bible warns of" - I suppose these could have different interpretations and are borderline but with your previous ban for racism I'm learning towards over the line.
You still haven't followed the correct format.
He can use the name "Bearded Jew" for all I care it's the dirty part that is not ok.
Questionable Moose
Banned
"Do you see that insert color of skin or religious belief man over there? He got a very dirty beard."
If the description is used in a context were pointing out the dirty beard is to express your belief that humanity are divided by races and some races are superior to another; then yes, I would agree that this ban are right.
"Dirty Bearded Jew" is not racism unless the context are as such, and in this case I will have to disagree with your judgement, Mittens. There is not enough evidence to prove the context of this case.
If the description is used in a context were pointing out the dirty beard is to express your belief that humanity are divided by races and some races are superior to another; then yes, I would agree that this ban are right.
"Dirty Bearded Jew" is not racism unless the context are as such, and in this case I will have to disagree with your judgement, Mittens. There is not enough evidence to prove the context of this case.
Questionable Moose
Banned
I evaluated your judgement based on the information that I could gather from this topic and his profile on hlstats where history of both his chat and aliases are available. The names that you have quoted are not visible for me (except Cyclosis example) so I could not include their usage in my statement.
If those names have been used by djb4837, then I will agree with the ban given. The context of some of those are clearly to provoke with racism. I do not understand why he did not get banned while under those older names when they have such a clear context behind them.
- Status