I'd give him a +1 from when I used to play here, but as I don't I can't do that..I do have a question though.
Why is his forum behavior counting against him? I've been here to see some people who don't even have forum accounts get admin. As far as I know it's quite possible for him to get server admin but not forum admin..they are two separate entities, and someone's behavior in one, should not effect the other (with exceptions of course.)
And as Furry said, if you're going to give negative feedback on someone, it does help to be a little explanatory.