New rating: dislike

[mittens]

For when something isn't dumb and you don't exactly disagree.

Dislike.

 

[KinCryos]

+1

would it be considered a neutral rating like Dislike and Optimistic?
or negative like Old, Dumb, Troll, and Confusing?

 

[ProbeX]

Ya did a good job flipin that like thumb into an dislike thumb. +1

 

[Lord Scrambles]

For when something isn't dumb and you don't exactly disagree.

Dislike.

The disagree function works perfectly well. Not everything needs a middle-ground solution. If you disapprove or disagree with something someone says, you can use the disagree button. If you feel like being a douche, you can use the dumb button.

 

[mittens]

+1

would it be considered a neutral rating like Dislike and Optimistic?
or negative like Old, Dumb, Troll, and Confusing?

Well since "like" is positive then it should be negative. But it's probably best to make it a neutral rating.

 

[KinCryos]

The disagree function works perfectly well. Not everything needs a middle-ground solution. If you disapprove or disagree with something someone says, you can use the disagree button. If you feel like being a douche, you can use the dumb button.

not true in MEEMEE TIEM. if someone posts a pic or vid you don't like, you can of course rate it Dumb, but how the hell do you disagree with it?

 

[JohnnyGaloshes]

+1

 

[Lord Scrambles]

not true in MEEMEE TIEM. if someone posts a pic or vid you don't like, you can of course rate it Dumb, but how the hell do you disagree with it?

In that case, you would be better off changing the "disagree" rating to a "disapprove" rating.

The word "disapprove" can mean either:

1. Have or express an unfavorable opinion about something.
2. Officially refuse to agree to.

The rating would be interchangeable and would work in both situations, perfectly. Keep it as a neutral rating, and you can completely avoid the need to create a new rating entirely.

 

[Ruelel]

shut up scrambles
+1

 

[KinCryos]

sounds like a good middleground

 

[Tomatketchup]

Let's also add unfunny, unwinning, uninformative, unfriendly, unuseful, unoptimistic, uncreative, unneat, unold, undumb, untroll and unconfusing. Middle grounds everywhere.

 

[PsychoRealm]

For when something isn't dumb and you don't exactly disagree.

Dislike.

I already see KSG yelling about Skial copying their ratings system :D
Also, Scrambles is right, imo. "Disagree" suffices.

+0 for now...

 

[KillerZebra]

Or you can be Cylosis and just punish people.

<3 you cylosis

 

[sov]

+1

In that case, you would be better off changing the "disagree" rating to a "disapprove" rating.

The word "disapprove" can mean either:

1. 
   Have or express an unfavorable opinion about something.
   Officially refuse to agree to.

The rating would be interchangeable and would work in both situations, perfectly. Keep it as a neutral rating, and you can completely avoid the need to create a new rating entirely.

I like this idea above so +1 but either way, an extra dislike/disapprove rating is very helping to express your self.

I already see KSG yelling about Skial copying their ratings system :D
Also, Scrambles is right, imo. "Disagree" suffices.



+0 for now...

I know of other forums that have the dislike button too.

 

[Mordy]

+1

Just like on Facebook right? :D

 

[staticvoid]

Still need a:
"You're fucking retarded"
rating

But yeah +1

 

[Sir Gooch P Tigglington]

inb4 this gets approved and mittens still gets his jollies by dumbing anyone and everyone to absolute fucking death for eternity.

 

[ViperStriker]

+1.

We added "Neat" as a rating, so hell, we could do anything.

 

[Pengy]

+1/2
It's a neat idea, but I doubt it will pass, and I haven't had any situations that require it to be necessary.
Hence, +1/2

 

[Party Chocobo]

If it stops Mittens from rating everything dumb then +1