Declined add ratings for LA Noire responses

[KinCryos]

I'm sure that many users wanted to do this to weak ban appeals:

so I'm suggesting that ratings for 'Truth', 'Doubt', and 'Lie' be added

Hidden

 

[Dragontamer]

+1 especially for doubt

 

[Doom4life]

-1. Why do we need to further promote toxicity on the forums? Sure some of the appeals are hackers and deserve the ban but how does the toxicity help the community look? It's bad enough that one user continues to have responses deleted in ban appeals yet this is posted in the heading:

If you are not the person that was banned/muted, you are only allowed to post evidence. Trash talk is unnecessary

I'll mention that there have been times when the assumption from this user was wrong and the ban was actually lifted.

Looking at another TF2 community, ban appeals have much less drama. A banned user appeals and admins reply. No public bashing from responses to the post to status posts. As an outsider, that looks more appealing then what regularly goes down here.

Besides, what's wrong with the box?

 

[Maddo]

Looking at another TF2 community, ban appeals have much less drama

Where's the fun in that?


-1 by the way, Just because I think there are too many ratings as it is. People can express themselves with words in a much better way, and if they can't... what are they even doing on a forum?

 

[KinCryos]

I think there are too many ratings as it is.

that's a valid point.
it's worth noting that the default Agree and Disagree ratings can be edited to use the names and icons of Truth and Doubt. that way, the number of ratings doesn't increase if only those two were to be implemented.

 

[Bottiger]

There are several reasons I do not want to add this.

• This meme is not going to be recognized in a year or more.
• If I only saw a blue X right now I wouldn't even know it was from this meme. I would absolutely not even know the yellow Y is lie or green A is truth and I don't think most people would know either.
• We're eventually going to have to upgrade this forum and this is another thing I'd have to remember to port.
  
• There are too many reactions already and they should be generic and because they are memes in my opinion.