Poll: Trade Server Map Replacement

[Drum]

So I made a suggestion a while back about changing up the trade server map.
Bringing it up again.
-----------------------
Updated. Fixing house of fun in its entirety will take a long time, as there are some pretty big issues with it.
I went ahead and checked out these maps, and they're suitable replacements.

dm_Area N9
http://gamebanana.com/tf2/maps/98940
This map is bigger than the current map, and also a bit sci-fi. 16mb. (This is my personal favorite).
pics:

Spoiler

trade_Face8
http://gamebanana.com/tf2/maps/159073
This is a very small map, 2.2mb.
This picture is the pretty much the entire map, sans the red / blue bases.
I imagine it would be very hectic with 32 players.

Spoiler

pic:

Trade_Park_v6
http://gamebanana.com/tf2/maps/165935
This is a fairly large map playerwise, 10.8mb.
Has features like a soccer court, volleyball area, a boxing ring for heavies.
pics:

Spoiler

Tron
http://gamebanana.com/tf2/maps/156964
9.59mb. Styled like Tron, this map has low ceilings and narrow corridors, so it'll be hectic with 32 players.
pics:

Spoiler

 

[KewnTunes]

We could at least have Trade Park up until Cyclosis finishes his because as I can see Bottiger has high expectations for the brand new one

 

[Faron]

US2
US1's map is fine

Vice-Versa IMO.

 

[sboles]

Can't view that link.

me neither

 

[Drum]

Vice-Versa IMO.

you don't like the minecraft one?

 

[ViperStriker]

The Minecraft and Portal Maps are god awful. I say put trade_bm_tower back on US1 and a new map on US2.

 

[Faron]

you don't like the minecraft one?

no. I don't particularly like the portal one, either. But its just what a trade map should be, or close to it.

Also the minecraft one is basically just a copy of rawr's, but with the nether and MC'd.

 

[Irish]

Trade #1 is filled all the time. Trade #2 is just overflow. Its a shit looking map and anything would still get the same traffic. I'd leave #1 alone with what has been shown here. Trade #2 is a visual disaster.

 

[Drum]

bump

 

[Faron]

Gonna choose Face8 cause it looks like Faron8!

 

[Cylosis]

Wasn't Cylosis already making one from scratch?

That thread is 3 maps outdated, but I've been toying with less linear map designs and displacements and think I might be onto something I can invest time into making.

It'll be original and playable this time, I promise.

 

[This Name Is False]

You want to replace our Portal map? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! ...Unless you find a better replacement, gl with that. Replace our Minecraft Trade, not Portal Trade. Too much nether camping.

 

[sboles]

You want to replace our Portal map? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! ...Unless you find a better replacement, gl with that. Replace our Minecraft Trade, not Portal Trade. Too much nether camping.

uhh ye-
I can't comprehend that.

 

[This Name Is False]

uhh ye-
I can't comprehend that.

Fine, I'll dumb it down for you. You cannot replace Portal trade! Replace Minecraft trade! It sucks! Portal is best anyway. You could replace Portal trade if you could find a better map (You can't, Portal wins by default). Although I like the first map listed.

 

[sboles]

Fine, I'll dumb it down for you. You cannot replace Portal trade! Replace Minecraft trade! It sucks! Portal is best anyway. You could replace Portal trade if you could find a better map (You can't, Portal wins by default). Although I like the first map listed.

no no no, I got that.
But I don't get how you say the portal map is GOOD
ALL people do it spam projectiles in a straight line! its horrible! I was sticky jumping and I FLEW OVER THE MAP. its horrible.

 

[This Name Is False]

no no no, I got that.
But I don't get how you say the portal map is GOOD
ALL people do it spam projectiles in a straight line! its horrible! I was sticky jumping and I FLEW OVER THE MAP. its horrible.

Fine, I'll dumb it down for you. You cannot replace Portal trade! Replace Minecraft trade! It sucks! Portal is best anyway. You could replace Portal trade if you could find a better map (You can't, Portal wins by default). Although I like the first map listed.

Ahem.

 

[Faron]

no no no, I got that.
But I don't get how you say the portal map is GOOD
ALL people do it spam projectiles in a straight line! its horrible! I was sticky jumping and I FLEW OVER THE MAP. its horrible.

Thats the fun of it. You can get behind a bunch of shit.

 

[sboles]

Ahem.

heres the thing, the MC map, is good, or at least PLAYABLE
the portal map, is bad.

 

[Cylosis]

no no no, I got that.
But I don't get how you say the portal map is GOOD
ALL people do it spam projectiles in a straight line! its horrible! I was sticky jumping and I FLEW OVER THE MAP. its horrible.

As someone who has opened the portal map in hammer for more than 4 seconds, I can confirm this.

It's an extremely shoddy map, both in design and build.


The minecraft one is shit as well.

 

[This Name Is False]

heres the thing, the MC map, is good, or at least PLAYABLE
the portal map, is bad, but still can't lose because Portal..

Fix'd. And yes, I'm just doing this because you can't grasp the truth.

 

[sboles]

As someone who has opened the portal map in hammer for more than 4 seconds, I can confirm this.

It's an extremely shoddy map, both in design and build.


The minecraft one is shit as well.

i looks like the creator just made it in Gmod.
And, atleast the MC one isn't bugged, has more room, and sentries don't dominate everything.