Amputator and Solemn Vow are both direct upgrades, so no.
Skial
DaivdBaekr
Meowcenary
Thanks
![[YDEK] fi$hy k!tty](/data/avatars/s/10/10707.jpg?1353037336){kind=avatar}
[YDEK] fi$hy k!tty
Only medic weapon that isn't considered a straight upgrade is the Vita-saw (less health) or the Ubersaw if you actually care about swing speed...
staticvoid
the 10 less health isn't really that bad. If you're trying to tank damage as medic, you're playing the class wrong. You really should never dip below 60 health as medic. Vita saw is good for pubs, but it is really good in comp, which is why it is banned.
Meowcenary
They banned the vita-saw in comp? wut
staticvoid
you can save a lot of uber, meaning you don't have to worry about an uber disadvantage as much. you wouldn't understand unless you played 6s or HL.
DanHack
I never played a comp game yet I understand...
Blade D_Hero
20% uber is big deel.
Ruelel
no point in using amputator after they removed the +1 health regen when you had the xbow equipped with it
staticvoid
When you're on spambowl you can heal all your red demomen friends all at once by taunting,
Ruelel
or just run quackfix and heal everyone with the dumb overpowered medigun
staticvoid
But kritz is good when you're already spamming